Why the Traditional SEO Playbook Falls Short in the AI Era
Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.
In today’s rapidly evolving digital landscape, the strategies that once secured prominent Google rankings no longer guarantee visibility on AI-powered platforms like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity. Unlike traditional search engines primarily driven by indexed web content, these AI engines generate answers predominantly from earned media — the one channel that businesses cannot buy, automate, or publish themselves. This fundamental shift redefines the role of public relations (PR) and highlights why understanding it is the strongest business case for PR in the last twenty years.
AI Engines Depend on Earned Media Over Owned Content
Try a quick experiment: open ChatGPT or Perplexity and ask for the best companies in your industry — the exact question a potential customer might pose. Then inquire what your company does and who its target audience is. Compare these AI-generated responses with your company’s carefully crafted positioning statements.
For many businesses, the AI’s portrayal doesn’t align with the intended message. Often, the descriptions are outdated by several years, borrow competitors’ framing, or reduce a nuanced value proposition to a bland, generic summary. This discrepancy is increasingly consequential. According to a Prosper Insights & Analytics survey, 53% of Americans using generative AI rely on it for internet searches. Unlike traditional search engines that display multiple blue links, AI platforms deliver concise summaries which users often accept as definitive.
The Editorial Hierarchy of AI Engines Places Earned Media at the Top
AI engines apply a clear editorial hierarchy when weighting sources. At the pinnacle sits third-party editorial coverage — content that has been vetted by journalists, editors, and fact-checkers. By contrast, owned channels such as your website, blog, and social media profiles rank much lower. The rationale is straightforward: businesses can make any claims on their own platforms, but earned media represents independently verified narratives.
Research conducted by my firm for a report on the attention economy revealed that ChatGPT attributes as much as 63% of its answers to traditional media sources. This means that the majority of what AI says about your company is derived from channels that many marketing plans treat as secondary to paid search.
Supporting this trend, Gartner predicts that PR and earned media budgets will double by 2027, largely driven by AI’s preference for trustworthy editorial content.
Earned Media: The Only Channel You Can’t Fully Self-Serve
Unlike paid advertising or owned content, earned media cannot be self-published. It exists only when an independent journalist deems your story newsworthy. This gatekeeping, while challenging, is precisely what gives earned media its credibility and value in the eyes of AI engines.
Building consistent media coverage requires a nuanced understanding that internal teams often lack. They are too close to their own narratives to objectively identify stories that resonate with journalists. PR professionals operate at the intersection of company messaging and journalistic interests, crafting pitches that align with what editors want to publish.
Moreover, establishing a competent in-house PR team involves significant investment: senior strategists to guide messaging, experienced leaders to oversee content, and junior staff to manage daily media relations. This structure typically costs more and distracts marketing departments from their core functions. The optimal approach is to manage strategy, content creation, paid media, and email marketing internally, while entrusting PR to specialized agencies.
It’s important to clarify what a quality PR agency delivers. Their value lies not in press releases alone, but in external messaging, positioning, media relations strategy, editorial judgment, and access to influential outlets. In the AI era, this combination is even more powerful, as AI engines not only index coverage but adopt the language used by credible media sources. From our client work, we’ve seen specific, memorable phrases from authoritative articles appear in AI-generated answers within days. Conversely, generic or poorly placed coverage forces engines to improvise, often resulting in diluted or inaccurate portrayals.
Unfortunately, some companies bypass specialist PR talent and distribute their own press releases directly to wire services. Without prior media relations, these releases rarely gain coverage and often read as overly promotional. In the AI context, this is counterproductive: unvetted, self-authored content on wire services is discounted by engines, wasting resources and producing no beneficial impact.
What to Expect From a PR Partner in the AI Age
Engaging a PR agency today demands new criteria. When evaluating partners, two key expectations should guide your decision.
First, insist on a thorough audit before pitching begins. The agency should assess what each major AI engine currently says about your brand using consistent queries and document those baseline answers. Success metrics must shift from traditional “clip counts” to tangible improvements in AI-generated narratives — with the goal that engines describe your business as you do.
Second, focus on strategy over contacts. Prospects often emphasize an agency’s relationships with publications or journalists. While access is important, it is table stakes for established firms. Last year, my agency placed stories with over 10,000 journalists, and a single story was picked up by 400 outlets. These numbers prove the existence of a distribution network but don’t guarantee influence.
The true indicator of effectiveness is the agency’s ability to craft strategies that reshape market perceptions — both within AI engines and among human audiences. When selecting a partner, request case studies detailing how their narratives have shifted client positioning and improved AI-generated descriptions. This editorial and strategic expertise is the skill you are purchasing.
As I’ve written previously, marketing goals must align directly with broader business objectives. Earned media serves as the vehicle to translate your story into narratives that influence markets — not only in readers’ minds but increasingly within AI-driven answers that shape customer perceptions.
For a detailed exploration of these themes, see Here.
